OMFG – serving other worldly cookie realness, the best cookies your find anywhere!!! Such creativity, design, and concepts… you’ll definitely come back. Owned and operated by the best people you’ll ever meet. And the coffee is badass too.

They have the best cookies ever! I stopped for breakfast and some wifi for a few hours in the morning. The place was so cute and cozy and the staff very nice. Coffee and cookies are great and wifi works just great. I loved their cookie box too =)

Delicious cookies! The flavors rotate on a daily basis so it’s nice to have options. There’s usually a partnership with a flavor based on a currently running Broadway show which is fun idea. The cookies and cream is a standout but the matcha one is my absolute favorite, though it’s rarely in the store which is kinda sad.

We went per a recommendation, and not disappointed. Great selection, fresh, and wonderful service! Cookies are large enough to share (or enjoy solo)😋 I look forward to returning next time I am in the area! 🍪😋

Wow, truly perfect classic chocolate chip cookie! I didn’t think it looked like my sort of cookie, but it really blew me away. Perfect crispness in in the crust but moist chewiness in the center, and a mouthwatering saltiness that made me salivate with every bite. This is definitely my new go-to treat!

Like cookies? Get here now! Wow, I was expecting overpriced big city bland cookies….uh not at all. These are very big, with creative mix-ins, and most importantly fresh (new flavors came out while we were in line at 7pm) and delicious. These were some of the tastiest cookies we have ever had. I know $3.75 may seem expensive but these are large, and unique, and in downtown NYC where a slice of cake is $9.00. You can buy a 6-pack for $18. Strong, fresh and reasonable priced coffee too. Highly recommended.

Wow! Incredible cookies and even better service! RJ was the nicest and most engaged person we met while in NYC on this trip! He knew everything about every cookie and gave us the perfect recommendations for any of our preferences! Will return!

Great cookies and great offerings! We got there before closing and got our cookies for “buy one get one free!” They also had gluten free and vegan options – it seemed that they have at least one gluten free and one vegan option each day. These cookies were everything we needed on a cold night! 🍪 You can bet we’ll be back for more!

Really tasty cookies! Liked Funfetti the best during this visit. What impressed me the most was the staff. It was my first visit and a staff member was so welcoming and helpful. While sitting outside, the staff member brought me a free hot chocolate since it was cold. I appreciate that type of service so much. Cannot recommend this place enough!

Really great large cookies and a location close to Times Square but far enough to not be overcrowded. There was a line but it moved quickly. Check back regularly because the flavors are always different. Highly recommend!

Hot and fresh cookies. Wow they have different varieties of cookies every time I visit. I can’t say which of them is my favorite. Each is very yummy and must try all. They are open till 12am. It makes it a nice dessert at the end of the day. They have some beverages that can be picked along with the cookies. Needless to say expect long queues over weekend and best if you take it to go.

Freshly baked cookies, does it get any better?

Service is always friendly. Cookies are always scrumptious. Line is always worth the wait.

I’ve been dreaming about these cookies since I had them a week ago. This place is the top reason I would move to New York, hands down.

Best cookies in NYC. Perfect amount of sweetness and chewiness.

Schmackary’s is better than Levain. They are able to accomplish both gooeyness and crunch in a uniformly shaped cookie. It’s perfectly done all the way through and that little bit of salt makes the biggest difference. This is my #1 cookie in NYC!

I first saw these cookies on IG and they looked delicious so I went to go buy some and they are amazing! If you have a sweet tooth this is the place for you.

Good gravy! The cookies are awesome! They are worth every penny. If there is a downside, it’s that the cookies are so good that it can sometimes result in a long wait to get them. But they are worth the wait!

The Hummingbird might be the best cookie I’ve ever had…

Omg. I walked into Cookie Heaven. Hands down one of the best cookies in my life.

Omg staff is amazing and never had a bad cookie ever

Best cookies in NYC. Amazing flavor options and combinations. This is a stop not to be missed before or after your Broadway show.

The cookies here have never disappointed. The flavors they have are all delicious. I never miss a chance to stop by whenever I’m in the area.

Everyone has their favorite cookie, this is mine. The cookies have a nice balance of sweet and saltiness that compliments their coffee beautifully.

The best cookies ever. Even if you are not cookie lover, you will love Schmackary’s cookies. Rosemary’s Baby is our favorite. Friendly staff and cute store.

Dropped in spontaneously with a few friends one chilly evening. Needless to say, we’ll be back. The cookies are heavenly, the staff are lovely, the decor is fabulous – what more could one want?

This after-show tradition is an unmistakable treat. If possible, splurge and get the half dozen to taste all the flavors. The sweet corn may sound weird, but it’s a little salty with plenty sweet. Best Cookie in NYC!

Best place for friends who love to munch on cookies best quality cookies and brownies made are here in this place youll love the service the theme of the place so gorgeous and amazing

Literally the best cookies in the whole world. Please open a location in Disney Springs! Or just in Orlando! Went back three days out of our five day vacation!

During peak times there’s bound to be a line out the door, but that’s only because the inside space is so small. It moves fast and is definitely worth the wait. All flavors are delicious, some extremely sweet if you’re looking for a dessert cookie. They also have savory cookies, vegan cookies and multiple gluten-free cookies. They don’t offer every flavor each day so don’t be too disappointed if they don’t have the one you’re looking for, try another. Cookies are great to eat yourself or give as gifts and come in a box. Worth a trip if you’re in midtown/hells kitchen.

so so good!! I was full…but kept eating more. its the kind of cookie that tastes so good you don’t want to swallow. you can’t go wrong with these cookies!!

The flavors are really inventive and complex. I’m surprised every time. It’s dessert perfected

Schmackary’s are SO. FREAKING. GOOD! Seriously, I can’t get enough!

The Julliard of bakeries…where cookies learn how to be their best. Funfetti and the chocolate chip (which have just a little sea salt) are must-haves.

The best cookies I’ve ever bought from a bakery and excellent service. Got the snickerdoodle, sugar cookie, & the oat Scottie. Even the coffee was fresh and delicious. I will be back!

The line for this place is always long even when it’s close to midnight. We came here on a weekend night looking for a midnight snack. we ended up getting the classic chocolate chip and cookies and cream cookies. The cookies were so large! My favorite one is the classic chocolate chip. The salt sprinkled on tasted perfectly with the cookie. Definitely a great place for a snack at any time of the day.

Amazing cookies and sweets, they’re just out of this world! Not too sweet, with many distinct tastes. The staff is very helpful, friendly and talkative, in a good way. Definitely a must if you’re in NYC, the best American cookies in town.

Oh my god!!! They have some of the best cookies ever.

Pros: Warm , delicious and finger licking good cookies. Reasonable prices. Welcoming and friendly staff. Quick service. Great location and they are open until midnight

Cons: Can’t think of any, I am busy devouring the last of the cookies I got.

Personal favorites : The Carrot cake and The Choconut chip

I have never eaten a better more delicious cookie. The entire menu- let me say it again… the whole entire menu is delicious. Service is fast and always good! And… I just found out they opened at Cooper Square which is very close to me. I will definitely be going there soon!

Great cookies! Love the interesting flavors they come up with. Even their chocolate chip with a little bits of salt is a nice take on a classic cookie.

One of my favorite spots in Hell’s Kitchen. Small and cute, cozy coffee shop full of sweets. You can get coffee or desserts in this lovely establishment. My favorites desserts from Schmackary’s are their famous cookies, especially Peanut Butter Cup, Cookies and Cream or Red Velvet. They have options of natural juices or sweet treats. They sell mugs and coffeee, brand related items as well. The best cookies in New York City. I stop by weekly, I’m a big fan of their delicious and tastefully desserts. I totally recommend this shop.

This place has excellent cookies. Hands down one of the best cookie shops in New York City. Many different varieties, made fresh at the shop. Small place and the line for service often forms out the door. Very popular place with tourists.

Holy taste buds! I BAKE FOR A LIVING! These guys have nailed the cookie game. We bought one of everything and each tried a piece of the heaven that is a cookie. Cozy, super friendly shop, very quick service and even gave my little girl a scoop of ice cream just because. Definitely a must stop in NYC. I WILL be ordering online in the future!

So many varieties of tasty cookies! Some classic, some with a twist. We left with a half dozen cookies, totally worth the line (it moves quickly). There are also tasty liquid refreshment options available for a good cookie-pairing, like milkshakes, coffee, hot chocolate, milk, whatever you want really.

Go! Have tasty cookies.

The Yogi Bare tastes like a chewy peanut butter granola bar and the Maple Bacon tastes amazingly! It’s salty and sweet at the same time and the bacon is crunchy which is perfect! Try this flavor when you come by!

We heard the line is usually around the block but when we arrived (due to rain) it was only a 10 min wait and it took our group that long to decide on our cookies anyhow… which we all shared and were unbelievably delicious. Ordering a coffee with the sweet baked delights is a must.

I do not stand in line at trendy places just so I can say I stood in line at the trendy place. However…. I would stand in line at Schmackary’s all day long if I had to. There’s something about their cookies. I go in with the intention of buying one and end up leaving with a box of six. And then I graze on them for two or three days. I try to stretch it out as long as I can because I just can’t stand the thought of not having some of their cookies in my apartment.

This place is the best. The people and the cookies are sweet. They have many creative flavors including vegan options. They also have brownies and shakes. And on a hot day a cool drink from the fridge works too. I am excited to get something delivered. You can order that online, in person & on the phone.

Really great place for dessert. We got there late and we got half price cookies which was amazing. So much variety of cookies with great friendly staff working. The cookies and cream cookies were amazing and the traditional chocolate chip cookies. Sooooo good!!! I highly encourage you to try it.

Came here for a cookie and got sideswiped by the salted caramel brownie. It did not disappoint! A moist, well priced piece of heaven. And the blueberry lavender tea was a great match.

I was craving something sweet so I decided to stop by Schmackary’s and they have an Excellent variety of cookies. With their many options I was sure to pick something of my liking. I had an ice cream sandwich and had the choice of two cookies for my ice cream sandwich. I chose the Peanut Butter Patty cookie and the Schmackerdoodle cookie (which was recommended by the great, friendly staff there). The flavor on the ice cream was vanilla. I Highly recommend the ice cream sandwich if you’re craving something sweet and happened to be near a Schmackary’s go for it. Make sure you grab a spoon if you take yours to go lol. Texture was good, cookies were fresh and soft, the size was well worth its price of $6.50.